It probably bugs Ric that this bugs me a bit, but I just see it as one signature detail whose importance is not yet known for certain; it also bugs me that others who are really bugged by this aren't bugged enough to dig deeper for more definitive evidence about that if what we're doing bugs them so badly.
It bugs me too. It's a fly in an otherwise perfect ointment. We're not ignoring it and we haven't dismissed it as unimportant. We have not said that 2-2-V-1 is definitely from the Miami Patch, nor will we. We'll publish our research so far (it now looks like it will be Monday) and we'll continue to learn as much as we can about the artifact. If we find something that legitimately disqualifies it as being from the Miami Patch we'll say so, but right now there is so much hard evidence that says it IS from the patch that it seems most likely that there is a reasonable explanation for the AD. Meanwhile we're not going to provide a stage for troll dances that contain nothing but opinion.
It isn't a perfect world.
You've just articulated very well why this is all worthwhile to many of us, despite the odds.
There is a big difference in topical skepticism and concerned research. I dislike wiping up other's spaghetti on the wall. I don't mind cooking, but if they throw it, they need to clean it up - otherwise they weren't examing my cooking, they just didn't like the meal.
Disraeli had something to say about this kind of thing - and we all deal in probabiliteis here, all the time. I've gone and looked at more fonts in person than I've seen posted here, so I know we're not getting a full picture and that 'A L C L A D' has not been pegged in time yet as to when it truly emerged; I also know what the 'A D' on 2-2-V-1 looks like, but am still not fully resolved that we have a clear, full picture of what we have for certain. Maybe I'm just dumb. I do note, however, that one reader recently pointed out what he thought was a subtle serif - and after the variations I've seen in Dayton I'm not sure that's not the case.
In any case, immature statistics can be the worst of veils. What we're trying very hard to do with 2-2-V-1 is to work through that as well as can be done - lots yet to do. Time...