Dr Moleski - in that second video there is no identified debris as yet.
Yes. That is why I spoke in terms of the "pictures under consideration."
Pictures of Norwich City debris were taken in one location.
The "pictures under consideration" were in a different location.
Now by any logical standards for the use of current data it cannot therefore be referred to as a debris field.
We won't know whether it is aircraft debris until after Niku VIII. I'm pretty sure I've mentioned this thought to at least twice before.
If at some time in the future something man made is positively identified then the next part of the process is to determine what it is, then if it is an aircraft part you must show that it is from the Electra, if you do that there is absolutely no need for another trip.
You have more faith in photographic analysis than I do.
I think TIGHAR will not know for sure what is in the photographs under consideration until after Niku VIII.
Nothing so far has been identified positively as alien to the natural sea bed material - organic or otherwise.
We are in complete agreement. I think the only way to find out what it is is
by observation. Observations cannot be made from the comfort of one's own home. The place to make the observations is in and near the location where the pictures under consideration were taken. That is why I recommend that TIGHAR undertake another expedition to the island. I should think they might call it Niku VIII.
In other words if people wish to claim that my assessment of the current film is wrong and my assessment of the field contamination argument is wrong then show me the evidence that contradicts me.
I can't show you the evidence, because it can't be obtained from looking at the pictures. I think someone will have to go back to Niku and examine the area where the pictures under consideration were taken. TIGHAR might be able to do it. They have some experience in doing underwater exploration of the Pacific atolls. If and when they go take a closer look, there may be evidence that will verify or falsify your opinion. Until then, it seems to be that it is an open question what the pictures under consideration show, if anything.