Forum logoHow accurate were the newspaper accounts in 1937?

After reviewing many articles written at the time of the disappearance, we’ve found that in most cases the papers went back for information to the orgy of publicity that preceded the first attempt in March. After the embarrassment of the Hawai’i wreck, AE was much less forthcoming with information as she prepared for the second attempt. Consequently, much of what “everyone knows” about how the airplane was set up is not necessarily accurate.

For example, all of the descriptions and cutaway views of the elaborate navigator’s station installed in the back of the cabin are based upon Manning and Mantz’s preparations and modifications of the airplane for the first attempt. Mantz, of course, was primarily a stunt pilot, while Manning was an accomplished nautical navigator, ham radio operator and amateur pilot. For AE’s part, her navigation on past flights had been purely dead reckoning and pilotage. In short, no one involved in the preparation had any real practical experience in long-distance celestial/radio aerial navigation. Noonan, who at least had the celestial part mastered, was not involved in the first attempt until only days before departure.

The result of all this was a tendency to over-equip the airplane. Earhart had taken a lot of flak for her 1935 Hawai’i to California flight which was denounced by many respected aviation figures (such as Al Williams) as a pointless stunt (which, frankly, it was). She was therefore pushing the world flight as a scientific endeavor. The Electra was described as a “Flying Laboratory” in which AE would perform experiments concerning pilot fatigue and gather specimens of air from the upper atmosphere during the flight. The truth was that the Electra was simply a current production airliner which had been modified to carry a whole lot of gasoline. The only really remarkable thing about the contemplated world flight was that it would be done in a land plane rather than a flying boat. Today we tend to forget that in 1937 it was possible to travel completely around the world by commercial airliner and, in fact, several journalists did just that to make the point.

The point of all this is, when we attempt to figure what was actually aboard the airplane when it left Lae we have to be careful to sort out the facts from the hype. Unfortunately, there is a lot more of the latter than there are of the former.


About TIGHAR Join TIGHAR The TIGHAR Store
TIGHAR Projects TIGHAR Publications Contract Services Field Schools
TIGHAR Forum Contact TIGHAR TIGHAR Home Site Map